Sadie finally knows what’s going on. Sort of. But it doesn’t matter. Cash Lincoln is out of her life.

Until he’s not.

When she runs into him in the mall food court a few weeks before Christmas, she thinks it’s just a chance encounter. That’s what he thinks, too.

But it soon becomes apparent that they still have some sort of connection—even though they both thought it was broken during their last encounter. There they are, stuck in a dark mall, while things get weird again. Weird… and watery. The mall starts to flood. A sailing ship appears in the parking lot. Pirates roam the halls. And a familiar figure stalks them once more.

As their fears emerge from the shadows to test them, Sadie finds herself faced with something she didn’t think she would get: a second chance. But is she brave enough to admit what she wants? Or is it too late to salvage a connection that’s been challenged by months of angst, doubt… and really weird narrative choices?